Consider this fair warning… There will be spoilers below. So, if you haven’t seen the episode and care about such things, stop reading now.
First, let me say that I mostly enjoyed the final episode. The first half of it was great, after that it went progressively downhill. I think that the episode was undone by the felt need to wrap up all of the various story lines in a nice package. This just didn’t feel right. It felt too easy.
BSG has been, primarily, about people figuring out how to live with each other and have a peace and a functioning community in the face of annihilation. It’s also about how people live with their technology, though I think less so until the final episode. For both of these themes, the journey should never actually end. The questions of how to live with each other and our technology should not be answered. It would have been arrogant of Ron Moore to try. Fortunately, he doesn’t try to answer the questions. Instead, he just punts them.
Abandoning your technology is not learning to use it responsibly. And, honestly, there’s no reason to believe that the human society would end up in pastoral peace in the Earth of the distant past. Why would humans and rebel cylons suddenly start getting along? Why is no one concerned that there might be other living cylons in the universe or that the the centurions that they free won’t come back? It’s just not believable.
I understand that Ron Moore was trying to directly tie the issues of the show into or present day situation. What he should have known is that everyone who watches the show gets that. They don’t need it reinforced with a hokey ending. So, I want to take a moment and look at what Ron Moore is really saying with his ending. I don’t think this is actually what he meant, but it’s what I think is there.
In the end, peace is delivered on a silver platter by God, the gods, or the supreme intelligence or whatever (GGSIW.) This kind of ending is always problematic and particularly when the people in the story have been through a lot of hardship, as have the characters in BSG. It leaves one to wonder why GGSIW waited so long to deliver the peace. Prior to the final episode, one might have decided that the GGSIW was guiding humanity so that they learn for themselves how to live with each other. This interpretation may still be valid, but it feels a little cheap when peace just pops out of your fourth birthday cake. More on this in a minute.
It’s not to much to assume that, by the end of the series, humans and cylons have learned a lot about their relationship with technology. Perhaps they would want to take the lessons that they had learned and use them in building a new society. But no, all technology goes into the sun so that 150,000 years later humanity can be in the same position yet again.
And this seems to be the actual plan of the GGSIW in BSG: To allow humans to advance to the point where they begin to have technology that could be used for self destruction and then force humanity to reboot itself entirely. The hope is that after a number of these iterations, random chance will result in a scenario where humans don’t destroy themselves. That’s it. The final scene of the show tells me that the law of averages is humanity’s best hope. Not learning from our mistakes or even the intervention of a benevolent GGSIW. Random chance. That’s it.
Ron Moore, was that really what you intended to say?
Tags:
bsg,
tv